Dr. Gaurav Patel, M.D.
Medical Doctor (M.D.)
Physician on our team who completes ESA evaluations and helps patients understand how their letter works for housing.
Mental health professionalIn a May 22, 2026 enforcement memo, HUD narrowed when its own investigators will find a violation in emotional support animal cases, after formally withdrawing the guidance that shaped those requests for more than a decade. Here is what the official documents actually say, what they leave untouched, and what tenants and landlords should do now.
Medically reviewed by Dr. Johnathan Miller, M.D.Updated October 9, 2026
On May 22, 2026, Craig W. Trainor, HUD's Assistant Secretary for Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, signed a memorandum to the Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity (FHEO) headquarters staff, enforcement staff and regional directors titled Enforcement Guidance on Assessing Requests to Use an Animal as a Reasonable Accommodation Under the Fair Housing Act. The memo applies "effective immediately" to complaints about animal-related reasonable accommodations.
The memo does two main things. First, it permanently rescinds FHEO's 2020 assistance-animal notice and reconfirms that both the 2020 and 2013 notices were rescinded on September 17, 2025. Second, it tells FHEO staff to find reasonable cause for a failure to waive a pet policy only where the animal has been individually trained to perform work or tasks directly related to the complainant's disability. In plain terms, HUD will no longer use its own administrative enforcement process to push housing providers to accept untrained emotional support animals (ESAs).
Two HUD documents are gone:
The formal withdrawal came first. A Federal Register notice published April 6, 2026 (FR-6571-N-01, also signed by Assistant Secretary Trainor) listed both notices among eight FHEO guidance documents withdrawn effective September 17, 2025, saying they "should not be relied upon as authoritative." The May 22 memo then explained the enforcement approach going forward.
The memo itself gives several reasons: a 2025 executive order (Executive Order 14219) directing agencies to de-prioritize enforcement not based on the best reading of a statute; the 2020 notice's failure to draw a clear line between pets and ESAs; the growth of an industry that converts pets into ESAs; the fact that the 2020 notice imposed categorical obligations without notice-and-comment rulemaking; a July 2025 federal court decision, Henderson v. Five Properties LLC (E.D. La.), which called HUD's notice "unpersuasive"; and HUD's finding that over 20% of FHEO's fair housing complaints revolve around untrained ESAs.
HUD now borrows the training concept from the Americans with Disabilities Act. Under the ADA, a service animal is a dog individually trained to do work or perform tasks for a person with a disability, and providing emotional support, comfort, or companionship does not count as a task. Under the memo:
HUD also says it intends to engage in notice-and-comment rulemaking on animal-related accommodations, with the aim of harmonizing its regulations with the ADA's to the maximum extent possible. That rulemaking has not been completed, and the public will have a chance to comment when a proposed rule is published.
| Area | Status after the memo |
|---|---|
| The Fair Housing Act | Unchanged. Refusing reasonable accommodations in rules, policies, practices, or services is still unlawful when they may be necessary for equal use and enjoyment of a dwelling. HUD's Federal Register notice says actions that do not comply with the Act's text remain subject to enforcement. |
| HUD's FHA regulations | Unchanged. The withdrawal notice withdrew guidance documents, not regulations, and any change to the regulations would come through future rulemaking. |
| Private lawsuits | Still available in federal or state court within two years after the alleged discriminatory practice. Both the memo and the Federal Register notice say they do not affect those rights. |
| State and local law | The memo does not discuss state law. State fair housing laws, several of which protect ESAs, still apply on their own terms. |
| Section 504 and the ADA | The memo says it does not address how HUD will process complaints under Section 504 or the ADA. |
| Individualized review | Animal accommodation decisions remain case-by-case and fact-specific. |
One more point: HUD guidance was never the law itself. It was HUD's interpretation, which courts could weigh. In private cases, courts decide under the statute, the regulations, and case law.
Because the Fair Housing Act lets individuals sue directly, a tenant whose ESA request is denied may still bring a claim in court without a HUD finding. Courts will decide those cases under the statute and case law, not the withdrawn guidance. As the memo notes, at least one court, in Henderson, held that waiving a generally applicable animal fee is not automatically required and must be shown to be necessary and reasonable.
State law is now often the deciding factor. California's fair housing regulations cover support animals as assistance animals, Illinois's Assistance Animal Integrity Act includes emotional support animals, and Minnesota's statute says a support animal does not need to be trained to perform a specific disability-related task. South Carolina's Human Affairs Commission announced in August 2026 that its state fair housing law still requires reasonable accommodations for assistance animals and does not require individual training. Florida's statute independently bars extra charges for ESAs. See our ESA laws by state guide.
For housing providers, the memo changes HUD's enforcement focus, not the statute. HUD's own documents point to a few practical cautions: the Fair Housing Act's text is still enforceable, tenants can still sue privately, decisions remain case-by-case, and HUD's rulemaking is still to come. State agencies have added their own guidance. South Carolina's Human Affairs Commission, for example, told providers not to change existing practices based on the HUD memo and to consult legal counsel before revising policies. Distinguishing trained animals from untrained ESAs, documenting each step of the interactive process, and following state law where it is broader all reduce risk. Our pet rent and deposits and no-pet policy guides cover those topics in more depth.
Same Day ESA Letter connects you with licensed mental health professionals for an ESA evaluation. You can book online 24/7. An ESA letter is $129 for up to two animals and $199 for three or more, and you get a full refund if you are not approved. Your letter does not disclose your diagnosis, and we do not sell registries, certificates, or ID cards, because those are not what housing providers rely on. A letter supports your request; it cannot guarantee how a landlord, school, or association will decide. See pricing and how it works for details.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Laws and agency policies change, and outcomes depend on your facts and your state. For advice about a specific dispute, talk with a fair housing attorney or your local fair housing agency.
It permanently rescinded HUD's 2020 assistance-animal notice (FHEO-2020-01), reconfirmed that both that notice and the 2013 notice (FHEO-2013-01) were rescinded on September 17, 2025, and directed HUD staff to find reasonable cause for a failure to waive a pet policy only when the animal is individually trained to perform work or tasks directly related to the person's disability.
Both were signed by Craig W. Trainor, HUD's Assistant Secretary for Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity. The withdrawal notice was published in the Federal Register on April 6, 2026, and the enforcement memo is dated May 22, 2026.
No. Nothing in the memo makes ESAs illegal or prevents a landlord from approving one. It changes how HUD enforces the Fair Housing Act, not the Act itself, and state laws protecting ESAs still apply.
Yes. The memo states that it does not affect the right to seek redress through a private action in court. Fair Housing Act lawsuits must be filed within two years after the alleged discriminatory practice, and state law may offer additional claims.
The memo does not address state law, so state and local fair housing laws still apply. Some states, like Minnesota, expressly say support animals do not need task training, and Florida bars extra charges for ESAs. Check your state's rules for updates.
The memo does not itself revoke approvals. South Carolina's Human Affairs Commission has warned housing providers that revoking a previously granted accommodation carries its own liability risk. Keep your approval and lease records on file.
For HUD to find reasonable cause, yes. But training is not required by the Fair Housing Act's text, and several state laws do not require it. Whether an untrained ESA is protected now depends heavily on your state and the facts.
HUD says it intends to engage in notice-and-comment rulemaking on animal-related accommodations, aiming to harmonize its regulations with the ADA's as far as possible. Until a final rule is issued, the existing regulations remain in place, and the public will have an opportunity to comment.
It depends on the state. Florida law bars extra charges for ESAs, and Minnesota and Maine bar fees or deposits for accommodated animals. Elsewhere, rules vary, and the court decision HUD cited held that a fee waiver is not always required.
Book a secure telehealth evaluation with a licensed mental health professional. Same-day letters once approved, from $129.
Keep reading
Every ESA evaluation is completed by a mental health professional licensed in the patient’s state, after a genuine telehealth evaluation.
Medical Doctor (M.D.)
Physician on our team who completes ESA evaluations and helps patients understand how their letter works for housing.
Mental health professionalMedical Doctor (M.D.)
Physician on our team who completes ESA evaluations and explains each patient's documentation and next steps clearly.
Mental health professionalReferences
Last reviewed October 9, 2026. General information, not legal or medical advice.
Answer five quick questions to see whether an ESA evaluation is a good next step. It takes about a minute and nothing is saved.